Sleek 49-storey tower could rise alongside Hummingbird
MARTIN KNELMAN
Some will see it as an elegant boot, the shape of a map of Italy, looming on Toronto's skyline and slouching toward the city's soon-to-be-reborn waterfront. For others, it will suggest a tall bird made of glass and steel.
Whatever you call it, Daniel Libeskind has unveiled a sleek new 49-storey tower set to rise alongside the Hummingbird Centre. Yesterday the plan was presented to the policy and finance committee of Toronto City Council, which conditionally recommended its approval.
But what, confused citizens might well wonder, became of the other proposed towers unveiled earlier with fanfare?
Take One: In early 2003, Dan Brambilla, CEO of the Hummingbird, unveiled a plan designed by Toronto architect Thomas Payne, which added wings and appendages to the 45-year-old performing arts centre.
Take Two: By July 2004, that plan was history, and city council was asked to approve a slender 50-storey residential tower designed by the Toronto architectural firm HOK.
Take Three: the Libeskind version, a poetic, swooping steel-and-glass icon.
"We incorporated elements of the previous two designs," says Alfredo Romano, CEO of the Hummingbird's development partner, Castlepoint Realty, "but each of them had certain problems and limitations. But it took Libeskind, one of the world's greatest architects, to give this landmark site the kind of unique quality it needs."
In a statement from his New York office, Libeskind who designed the Jewish Museum in Berlin and did the master plan for the redevelopment of the World Trade Centre in New York said: "This building is a gateway at the crossroads of the city, linking the financial district to the north, the waterfront to the south and the St. Lawrence neighbourhood to the east."
Brambilla's plan calls for the tower to complement a renewed arts centre, which he dubs City Centre, retaining the theatre but adding an ambitious and diverse series of cultural programs, including an interactive arts lab, a tourist-information service and a dinner-theatre video cabaret.
Libeskind's design includes a seven-storey box at the base of the tower that extends toward the original building on the Yonge St. side. The seven storeys at the base of the tower would be devoted to Brambilla's cultural program. The Yonge St. box also features a huge, rounded glass window and space for the public to gather, as well as a cafe.
The project design includes a second horizontal flank, on the south side of the property, along the Esplanade, which would mask the Hummingbird's unsightly fly tower and provide a garden-like setting for those looking either up or down at it.
There's a catch. The cost of Brambilla's City Centre extravaganza is $71 million, of which $15 million would be contributed by Castlepoint in exchange for the right to build the tower, leaving $56 million that would have to be raised. And the city wants to ensure that if his business plan fails, that box won't turn into a shopping mall.
Yesterday the finance committee suggested there would be two possible ways of going ahead with Libeskind's tower. Plan A: If Brambilla can raise the money for City Centre, proceed with the whole project. If not, build the tower for now, and leave City Centre for later.
"What makes the project unique is the combination of its spectacular location and its visionary program," says Yama Karim, project architect and a senior associate at Libeskind's firm. "This is not just another tower conceived with the idea of maximizing square footage and revenue. It's a landmark project intended to enrich the city and contribute to its liveliness, creating a place where cultural activities and residential facilities have been blended."
Romano, the developer, said at yesterday's city hall meeting that the proposal reflects a sense of respect for both Peter Dickinson's original milestone building and for the neighbourhood in which it is situated.
Comparing his proposal to Cesar Pelli's Museum Tower atop the Museum of Modern Art in New York, Romano said: "There are a number of firsts with this project, including a fully integrated affordable housing component consisting of 40 rental units."
Source